The Court of Appeal has overturned a ruling that could
have compromised UK farming's ability to apply
pesticides.
We reported in the 2008 November Agricultural bulletin
on the High Court's ruling in a case brought by Georgina Downs.
This found that the UK Government had breached EU rules on safe
pesticides application.
The High Court had applied a strict interpretation of the
wording of the European Directive, which effectively meant that no
pesticide could be used unless it could be established that it had
no harmful effect on human health.
The Court of Appeal has taken a much more risk-based approach:
"The current risk-based system acknowledges that the danger
posed by a substance does not just depend on how toxic it is, but
is also affected by how it is used in the real world. An example
often used is a cup of coffee: it contains many carcinogens, but
levels are low and the body processes them naturally and
effectively."