Ms Hathway and Mr Hudson started a relationship in 1990. They
had two children but did not marry. They bought a family home in
joint names, with no declaration of trusts. Both worked, but Mr
Hudson substantially paid the mortgage; the amount he contributed
exceeded Ms Hathway's contributions. The parties
separated.
Then in 2011, the house was blighted by an oil spill, making it
very difficult to sell. In July and August 2013, Mr Hudson and Ms
Hathway agreed financial terms set out in emails. This
included that Ms Hathway would get the house which Mr Hudson
described as "a bad asset which is preventing all of us
[from] .. moving on with our lives".
In October 2019, Mr Hudson issued his claim for the sale of
house, with equal division of the proceeds. Ms Hathway agreed that
the house should be sold but contended that she was entitled to the
whole of the proceeds under a constructive trust following a common
intention and agreement, in reliance on which she had