Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 09 OCTOBER 2009

The Right To Privacy: A Right Without A Remedy

The identities of Baby P's killers have recently been disclosed officially. The court order prohibiting such disclosure was lifted because it ceased to be necessary.

United KingdomPrivacy
Claire Cartwright-Hignett
Claire Cartwright-Hignett

The identities of Baby P's killers have recently been disclosed officially. The court order prohibiting such disclosure was lifted because it ceased to be necessary. The sad fact is that the order was ineffective to prevent bloggers from disclosing the identities months before the courts had deemed it appropriate to do so.

Baby P's siblings are innocent and yet they have, by implication, been named alongside Baby P's killers. Each sibling has their own right to privacy which incorporates a right to control their identity. Public disclosure of their identities constitutes a breach of their right to privacy. The damage they suffer is immediate, irreparable and enduring.

Disrespect for the court order prohibiting disclosure of Baby P's killers meant that the identities of the wrongdoers and, implicitly, the identities of Baby P's siblings, were spread over the internet whilst an order restraining disclosure was in place. This has two effects:

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from