Harbottle & Lewis represented its client Pets at Home in
this matter and secured an on air broadcast of the BBC Trust
ruling.
John Kelly, a partner in the firm's Reputation Protection
team, said: "This is likely to be the last finding by
the BBC Trust which will be disbanded after 3 April. It will be
interesting to see how the BBC Board will adjudicate on such
matters when it takes over from the BBC Trust in April. There is
clearly a need for an independent body to ensure compliance with
the BBC editorial guidelines."
The BBC Trust found that there had been a "failure of due
accuracy relating to the item as a whole, as well as failures of
the guidelines on impartiality, privacy and fairness relating to
various points. Together these constitute a serious breach of the
editorial guidelines and warrant an appropriate broadcast summary
of the Trust's findings. The item must also be removed from the
website."