The ink is barely dry on the pages of The Digital Economy
Act 2010 ("DEA") and yet its legality is already being
questioned. Two of the largest ISPs, BT and Talk Talk have
announced their intention to seek a Judicial Review of the Act on
the grounds that it was subject to insufficient parliamentary
scrutiny and is not ECHR compliant. Hardly an auspicious
start...
The Act was intended to implement the Digital Britain Report
which was published with great fanfare in June 2009. However
by the time the first draft of the Bill was published in Nov 09 it
was already apparent that its passage was liable to be affected by
the looming General Election. The Act was eventually passed
in April 2010 but several of its more radical provisions were
sacrificed in the "wash-up" procedure, the horse trading
between political parties which occurs when legislation is hurried
through before the dissolution of Parliament.