A recent UK High Court decision1 illustrates how a
news report which may be defensible at the time it was first
published can lose the benefit of that defence over time if it
remains available on line. The case also indicates how a
publisher's interaction with a defamation plaintiff can
increase the sum of damages awarded.
Publishers should carefully consider updating and amending
online publications following the outcome of an investigation or
similar inquiry where the subject is cleared and has complained
about the earlier reports, unless a defence of truth or fair report
is clearly available.
Background – The Times article
On 2 June 2006, the Times published an article in print and
online under the heading "Detective accused of taking bribes
from Russian exiles". The article identified Gary Flood, an
officer in the Metropolitan Police Service Extradition Unit, as
being the subject of a police investigation into allegations that
he was paid by a British