Claims to recover losses on derivatives are often as speculative
as the trades themselves. But throw a fraudulent broker into the
mix and everything changes, as last week's case of
Parabola Investments Ltd v Browallia Cal Ltd &
Ors demonstrates.
The High Court awarded some £20 million to Tangent, an
investment vehicle run by Rajesh Gill, a well-known trader with an
enviable track record trading in "market makers". Mr Gill
had relied on daily dishonest misrepresentations by a Man Financial
Group broker that his trading in CFDs (contracts for differences)
was profitable.
Not only did the Court find that the broker ought to make good
the losses on trades, but it also awarded damages for the profits
Tangent would have probably made on alternative investments. Flaux
J went further and held that the lost profits should be calculated
not just for the period of the fraud, but up to the date of
trial.