The ongoing US restitution case, Maestracci v. Helly Nahmad
Gallery, Inc., concerns a Modigliani painting allegedly looted
by the Nazis. It highlights the practice of using corporate shell
companies to allow collectors to anonymously hold art, and is an
example of the recently enacted United States legislation 'the
Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act' in action.
When the Jewish art dealer Oscar Stettiner was forced to flee
the Nazi invasion of Paris in 1939 he left behind his art
collection that included Modigliani's Seated Man With a Cane
(1918). Subsequently, a Nazi appointed administrator sold the
Modigliani in July 1944, without Stettiner's consent.
Stettiner filed a claim against both the administrator and the
buyer of the painting in Paris in 1946, to try to reclaim the
Modigliani. Stettiner was successful and the court ordered that the
work must be returned to him. However, court records from 1947 show
that the buyer said he had given the painting to