As critical minerals become geopolitically strategic, resulting disputes become political. Investor-state (or investment treaty) arbitration is a common forum for such disputes. Daniel Wilmot, International Arbitration partner at Stewarts asks: Does this present a challenge for such arbitration? If so, how should it acknowledge such reality?
Across Africa, a “new wave” of mining disputes is emerging. A recent data-led analysis by Stewarts, a disputes-only law firm, identified 43 publicly reported mining-related investor-state arbitrations brought or contemplated against African states between 1 January 2020 and 24 June 2026.
The disputes analysed concerned bauxite, graphite, uranium, lithium, cobalt, copper, and gold. Many arose from measures affecting mining rights, including revoking or suspending licences, changing regulatory frameworks, refusing to extend or implement operating arrangements, and removing control over mining assets.