Legitimate spare part or counterfeit?
Rolex has issued proceedings in the U.S against Vintage
Watchmaker LLC for offering "non-Rolex approved"
replacement parts. Rolex argue that these turn an otherwise
legitimate Rolex watch into a counterfeit good.
This raises the question of whether a genuine good can become a
counterfeit product by virtue of replacement parts not supplied or
authorised by the original manufacturer.
The World Intellectual Property Organisation defines counterfeit
goods as "any goods bearing, without authorisation, a
trade mark identical to the trade mark validly registered in
respect of such goods, or which cannot be distinguished in
essential aspects, thereby infringing the rights of the
owner." In this case the traditional definition of
counterfeit does not necessarily appear to be present. The watch
itself is legitimately bearing the Rolex mark, but do
"non-Rolex" spare parts make it counterfeit?