Two recently issued and differing decisions have muddled what
used to be a routine, albeit peculiar, part of European patent
prosecution. Having successfully prosecuted your claims before the
EPO, should you adhere to an examiner's request to amend your
description or not? That is, all of a sudden, a tricky
question!
For many years, a routine part of European patent prosecution
involved the examiner requesting the Applicant review their
description to ensure that it did not extend beyond the scope of
claims to be granted. Where the description was found to refer to
embodiments construed as falling outside the scope of the granted
claims, an amendment would be required to bring the two into
alignment.