There has been yet another decision on the question of what
constitutes "waste".
A string of cases in recent years have attempted to define what
constitutes "waste" and when waste can safely cease to be
classed as such. The most recent judgment is the Court of Appeal
decision in R v W, C and C (11 May 2010).
The case started when the owners and manager of a farm (the
"farmers") were charged under section 33 of the
Environmental Protection Act 1990 ("the Act") with:
- knowingly permitting the deposit of controlled waste without a
waste management licence; and
- disposing of or keeping controlled waste without a waste
management licence.
They were being prosecuted because some 9,126 tonnes of soil and
subsoil had been deposited at their farm between 2007 and 2008. The
farmers had been paid over £20,000 to receive these
materials. There was no waste management licence. (NB "waste
management licences" have subsequently become
"environmental permits".) The soil