Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 27 JUNE 2011

Punishing Contempt

Joanna Fraill, the juror who used Facebook to contact Jamie Sewart, the acquitted defendant whose case she tried, was last week sentenced to 8 months’ imprisonment.

United KingdomCriminal Law

Joanna Fraill, the juror who used Facebook to contact Jamie Sewart, the acquitted defendant whose case she tried, was last week sentenced to 8 months' imprisonment. The Attorney General's decision to prosecute both women sends a clear warning to jurors that they will be punished severely if they act in contempt of court. But is the threat of prosecution the only way in which the jury system can respond to the challenges of the internet age?

Two aspects of this case were particularly troubling. The first was Ms Fraill's admission that she was doodling throughout the trial: "all I was doing was just killing time [...] drew more than I wrote." This somewhat boastful assertion of irresponsibility will be cited by critics of the jury system as evidence that jurors may be unable or unwilling to concentrate on the minutiae of a criminal trial. There is some force in this criticism. But it would be too simplistic to attribute this failing solely to a broken society in which

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from