"Consequently, the applicant was not entitled to benefit from the collective bargaining agreement as she was classified as excluded personnel. However, the failure of the courts to provide relevant and sufficient reasoning in this respect is incompatible with the State's positive obligations within the scope of ensuring an effective judicial review required by the right to union.
For the reasons explained above, it must be held that the right to union, safeguarded under Article 51 of the Constitution, has been violated." (Hülya Şimşek [Plenary], App. No: 2022/18821, 20 March 2025, § ...)
In the Constitutional Court's judgment, an excerpt of which is provided above, the Court held that the reasons for excluding an employee from the scope of the collective bargaining agreement were neither lawful nor justified and therefore ruled that compensation be awarded to the employee who had been excluded from the agreement.