In International Chamber of Commerce ("ICC")
arbitrations, new claims that are subsequent to the terms of
reference are subject to the arbitral tribunal's authorization.
Article 23(4) of the ICC Arbitration Rules ("Rules") give
discretion to the arbitral tribunal by setting forth that the
arbitral tribunal shall consider the nature of new claims, the
stage of the arbitration, and other relevant circumstances.
The issue of new claims in ICC arbitrations and the application
of Article 23(4) in these matters are analyzed in this article.
In General
In ICC arbitrations, the terms of reference play an important
role. One of the purposes of the terms of reference is to establish
the parties' claims. The terms of reference contain, among
other things, the relief sought by the parties. If the parties make
claims that fall outside of the scope of the terms of reference,
the provisions to be applied to these new claims shall be
determined.