Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 02 MARCH 2018

Objective Scope Of Res Judicata Of Arbitral Awards - Is There Room For Discretion?

In its landmark decision DFT 141 III 229 dated 29 May 2015 - also known as the "US law firm decision" -‚ the Swiss Federal Tribunal confirmed its previously established doctrine on the controlled transfer of a foreign award's effects ...

SwitzerlandLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration

In its landmark decision DFT 141 III 229 dated 29 May 2015 - also known as the "US law firm decision" -, the Swiss Federal Tribunal confirmed its previously established doctrine on the controlled transfer of a foreign award's effects ("Kontrollierte Wirkungsübernahme") for the determination of the objective scope of res judicata of a foreign arbitral award. The concept implies, amongst other things, that the binding effect of a foreign award being recognised in Switzerland cannot go beyond the determinations contained in its operative (or dispositive) part.

Such narrow approach to res judicata has been criticised by various authors. The concept is considered inappropriate in the context of international arbitration by some scholars because arbitrating parties ordinarily wish to have their disputes resolved in a comprehensive manner. Given the lack of any pertinent and authoritative transnational principles, it is further argued that arbitral tribunals should be

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from