Earlier this year the Swedish Patent and Market of Appeal Court
(PMAC) delivered a notable judgement, which concerned alcohol
marketing claims including subjective opinions.
In 2016, the Swedish Consumer Ombudsman (CO) requested an
injunction on the use of the following statements within alcohol
marketing: “BARGAIN!”, “RECOMMENDED!” and
“AN EXCELLENT ALTERNATIVE TO THE BIG PARTY!”. These
third party reviews was used in the advertisement of the wine
“Charles De Fére Rosé Brut”. The CO
argued that the use of these claims was in breach of the
requirement of specific moderation when marketing
alcohol in Sweden.
The first instance, the Swedish Patent and Market Court (PMC)
considered that “RECOMMENDED” was in line with the
requirement of specific moderation since there was a
distinct connection to the reviews. However, the claim of
“BARGAIN!” or “AN EXCELLENT ALTERNATIVE TO THE
BIG PARTY!” was found incompatible with the same requirement.
“BARGAIN!” was perceived as a