A judgment that needed a few more minutes on the boil
Soft Coffee (Pty) Ltd v Nonnas Pasta (Pty) Ltd and Others (Case No. 088838/2025, High Court of South Africa, Gauteng Division, Pretoria. Judgment delivered 22 June 2026 by Mooki J.)
The recent decision in Soft Coffee v Nonnas Pasta is, in many respects, a model of how trade mark infringement should be adjudicated. The court was decisive in stripping away irrelevant noise, faithful to the notional use doctrine, and doctrinally rigorous in disposing of a section 36 defence that had never been properly pleaded. Where the judgment disappoints is in its treatment of the infringement finding itself — where a failure to distinguish between sections 34(1)(a) and (b) of the Trade Marks Act has produced an interdict that goes further than the reasoning can support, with real consequences for the respondent.