An article that appeared in the South African Daily
Maverick news site, “Plain packaging for cigarettes is a
bad idea”, suggests that the plain packaging debate
is not yet over.
A recap
We’ve discussed plain packaging for cigarettes on a number
of occasions. We’ve looked at how Australia has been at the
forefront of this issue, with 2011 legislation requiring all brands
of cigarettes to be sold in identical green packs featuring graphic
images. We’ve seen how the Australian High Court held that
the legislation is lawful, and that it does not involve unlawful
expropriation of property. We’ve seen how plain packaging
legislation was held to be lawful in the UK, with the Court of
Appeal taking the view that the trade mark right is the negative
right to exclude others from using it rather than the positive
right to use it, and that this negative right to stop others is not
affected by plain packaging regulations.