The issue of a plain packaging requirement for tobacco products
has been a hot topic since mid- 2012. That’s when the
Australian High Court ruled that the Australian law that requires
cigarette manufactures to sell their products in packages which
contain little more than a prominent health warning and the brand
name of the product in small and plain script – no
stylizations, logos, colours, or any of the other identifying
features typically associated with products. When the South African
Health Minister, Aaron Motsoaledi, indicated that he would like to
see similar legislation enacted in South Africa, there was an
immediate reaction. This came in the form of warnings that such
laws would amount to an unconstitutional expropriation of
(intellectual) property, which would require the government to pay
huge sums in compensation to cigarette manufacturers who had been
deprived of their trade marks.