South Africa's Supreme Court of Appeal
("SCA") has handed down an important
trade mark judgment. The case of PepsiCo Inc v Atlantic
Industries deals with the issues of distinctiveness and
likelihood of confusion, with a special emphasis on sub-brands.
There are a lot of important points in this short judgment, so I am
going to quote liberally.
The facts: PepsiCo applied to register the trade mark Pepsi
Twist (with and without a device) for soft drinks. The applications
were opposed by Atlantic Industries
("Atlantic") on the basis that they
clashed with their existing registrations for Twist, Lemon Twist
and Diet Twist in the name of Atlantic; so PepsiCo counter-applied
for the cancellation of the earlier registrations.