South Africa finally has its first Adwords decision. Judge
Nicholls of the Gauteng Local Division handed down judgment in the
case of Cochrane Steel Products Pty Ltd v M-Systems Group (Pty)
Ltd on 29 October 2014.
An Adwords case is a case where the issue is this: is it
lawful for company A to purchase the trade mark of company B as an
Adword in order to ensure that when anyone searches company B's
trade mark they get to see company A's adverts?
Cochrane is the owner of the trade mark ClearVu in respect of
fencing. M-Systems is a competitor that sells a product under the
trade mark M-Secure. M-Systems admitted that it bids on the Adwords
'clearvu', 'clear vu' and
'clear-vu', but denied that this is unlawful.
Cochrane felt aggrieved by this, claiming that anyone who searches
ClearVu is obviously looking for its product rather than the
product of M-Systems. It felt particularly upset by the fact that,
because the market for Adwords is an open one with the price