A case study of Wilson Taylor Asia Pacific Pte Ltd v Dyna-Jet
Pte Ltd [2017] SGCA 32
Introduction
The recent Singapore Court of Appeal judgment in Wilson
Taylor Asia Pacific Pte Ltd v Dyna-Jet Pte Ltd discusses the
legal implications of an arbitration agreement of an asymmetrical
nature. Such an arbitration agreement is one which confers a
unilateral right (i.e. a right which is enjoyed by only one party
to the arbitration agreement but not by the other) on one party to
elect whether to arbitrate a future dispute.
Due to the unilateral right conferred on one party, it can be
said that the arbitration agreement lacks mutuality
between the parties. Also, given that one party has the choice of
whether to submit the dispute to arbitration or litigation, there
is also an element of optionality introduced into the
arbitration agreement. However, these two factors did not prevent
the court from finding that arbitration agreements of an
asymmetrical nature are valid