On 4 November 2026, the Civil Court (Commercial Section), presided over by Mr Justice Ian Spiteri Bailey (the “Court”), delivered judgment in the names John Baldacchino (the “Plaintiff”) vs J.P. Baldacchino & Co Limited, Adrian Baldacchino and Dennis Baldacchino (together, the “Defendants”). Finding that the family-run building materials company had been managed in a manner that unfairly prejudiced the Plaintiff as a shareholder, the Court ordered the company to pay him €100,000, together with interest, and appointed an independent chairperson to oversee its general meetings for three years.
Background
J.P. Baldacchino & Co Limited (“JPB”), a company established by Anthony Baldacchino in 1974, operates in the importation and sale of construction materials. In 2008, Anthony transferred shares to his three sons: John and Adrian each received 213,372 shares, Dennis received 213,371 shares, while Anthony retained 57,885 shares. John remained a director until his resignation in August