The Italian State Council to tip the scale in favor of a
deeper judicial review of antitrust misconduct.
In the Italian public enforcement matter La Roche-Novartis
v. Antitrust Authority, the State Council (the administrative
court of second instance, which has exclusive jurisdiction on
antitrust cases) recently issued a hallmark decision (4990/2019)
addressing a long-debated thorny issue: the breadth of the
administrative court's judicial review of the facts underlying
antitrust fines imposed by the Antitrust Authority as part of an
investigation.
The State Council focused on how to perform an effective
judicial review so as to ensure that the Antitrust Authority and
the fined entity stand against each other on a level playing field
under the umbrella of due process principles and without
undermining the independence of a public body.