The European Union's Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act)
is shaping up to be one of the most significant regulatory
frameworks for AI, potentially setting a global benchmark.
While the Act provides a clear classification of what
constitutes a “high-risk” AI system, particularly those
listed in Annex III, the inclusion of certain derogations adds a
layer of complexity. These derogations allow organisations to
self-assess and determine whether their AI systems, despite being
listed in Annex III, actually warrant the high-risk label.
However, this flexibility also introduces a significant
challenge: a lack of clarity. For many organisations, the process
of self-assessment may be fraught with uncertainty. The
derogations, while offering a route to avoid the heavy burdens of
high-risk classification, can also make it more difficult to
decisively categorise an AI system. The ambiguity surrounding
whether a system is high-risk or not may lead to confusion,
potentially