Brian Nolan and Sunday Newspapers Limited Trading As The
Sunday World [2019] IECA 141
A recent Court of Appeal decision provided some interesting
comments on the right to privacy in the context of photographs
published by media organisations, where those photographs, obtained
through legal means, are of a private individual at a private
party.
Facts
The plaintiff issued proceedings claiming defamation and a
breach of his constitutional right to privacy arising out of two
articles published by the defendant.
The articles, viewed by the Court of Appeal Judge as being
"salacious in nature", were accompanied by
photographs of the plaintiff attending what were described as sex
parties or "swingers' parties" in the
company of females who were "scantily clad". The
photographs had been provided to the defendant by the
plaintiff's then partner, following the break-up of the
relationship. The plaintiff gave evidence that some of the
photographs were not even taken at