Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 17 SEPTEMBER 2012

Withholding Consent In A Commercial Context – What’s Reasonable?

In the recent case of Porton Capital Technology Funds & Ors v 3M UK Holdings Ltd & Anor, the English High Court considered the relevant principles to be applied where a Share Purchase Agreement ("SPA") provided that the purchaser of the business could not cease to carry on the business without the vendor’s consent.

IrelandCorporate/Commercial Law

In the recent case of Porton Capital Technology Funds & Ors v 3M UK Holdings Ltd & Anor1  the English High Court considered the relevant principles to be applied where a Share Purchase Agreement ("SPA") provided that the purchaser of the business could not cease to carry on the business without the vendor's consent, such consent "not to be unreasonably withheld".  The case provides useful guidance on the meaning to be applied to this phrase in a commercial context.


Background

The defendant purchased Acolyte Biomedica Limited ("Acolyte") under a SPA in February 2007.  The consideration consisted of £10.4m in cash and an earn-out payment based on net sales for the year 2009, capped at £41m.  The claimants represented 60% of the shareholder vendors.  Acolyte's product was a product used in detecting MRSA called BacLite.  The business subsequently failed and it ceased in December 2008.  There were therefore no sales in 2009, to form the basis of the

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from