In 1997, the Supreme Court of India (Supreme
Court) pronounced its judgment in the case of
People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) v. Union of
India (SC, 1997) (PUCL Case), which
laid the groundwork for the right to privacy in the context of
telephonic surveillance (i.e. wiretaps) and constitutional
freedoms.
This article analyses the Supreme Court's stance on the
right to privacy in the PUCL Case, which was upheld in the 2017
landmark judgment by the nine-judge bench in KS Puttaswamy v.
Union of India (SC, 2017) (Puttaswamy Case)
that declared privacy a fundamental right. The applicability of the
right to privacy has recently received further validation in the
context of wiretaps in the October 2019 judgment in Vinit Kumar
v. Central Bureau of Investigations and Ors (Bom HC,
2019) (Vinit Kumar Case), wherein the Bombay
High Court outlined the ambit of the State's power to surveil
its subjects particularly on matters that do not fall within the
category of 'public