Introduction
Appointment of serving or ex-employees of a contesting party as
arbitrators continues to beleaguer the entire arbitration
community. Although this issue has been put to scrutiny before
various Courts but it is yet to be resolved determinatively. Such
appointments are questionable on account of apparently being in
conflict with the sanctimonious principle of impartiality in
arbitration, as the appointment of such persons as arbitrators
would naturally bring a presumption of bias in favor of the party
with whom they are or have been associated with. In order to ensure
independence, neutrality and impartiality in the process of
appointing the arbitral tribunal, Section 12(5) r/w the Seventh
Schedule was introduced by way of the 2015 Amendment to the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 ("the Act").
Section 12(5) provides that any person whose relationship with
either party to the dispute falls within the relationships
specified under the Seventh Schedule,