1. Introduction
1.1 Does entry in balance sheet of a company amount to
acknowledgement for the purposes of Section 18 of Limitation Act,
1963 ("Limitation Act")? The answer to
the question, which seems so apparent in view of a catena of cases,
both domestic and foreign, seems to have been turned on its head by
a decision of National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
("NCLAT") in its recent decision
rendered in the case of V. Padmakumar v. Stressed Assets
Stabilisation Fund (SASF)1 ("Padmakumar
Decision").
1.2 The majority decision, which was rendered by a 4:1 majority
of an unprecedented five-member bench of NCLAT, ruled that
entry in balance sheet/ annual return, which is required to be
prepared to comply with statutory requirements, cannot be treated
to be an acknowledgement under Section 18 of the Limitation
Act. Notably, the majority decision had reiterated the
decision of the two-member bench of NCLAT in the earlier case of
Sh. G Eswara Rao v. Stressed Assets