The Supreme Court recently split open another issue that was
previously considered settled – the enforceability of an
arbitration agreement incorporated in an unstamped contract. The
decision of the Supreme Court was given recently by a three-judge
bench in the case of NN Global Mercantile Pvt Ltd v Indo
Unique Flame Ltd & Others.
The bench disagreed with two previous judgments of the Supreme
Court on the issue:
(1) SMS Tea Estates Pvt Ltd v M/s
Chandmari Tea Co Pvt Ltd, where it was held that a court
cannot act on an arbitration agreement forming part of an
instrument unless the stamp duty has been paid on that instrument;
and
(2) Garware Wall Ropes Limited v
Coastal Marine Constructions and Engineering Limited, where it
was held that an arbitration clause does not exist, as a matter of
law, if it is in an agreement that is not duly stamped.