It has become increasingly common for parties to adopt
multi-tiered dispute resolution clauses in agreements. A typical
multi-tiered dispute-resolution clause requires parties to first
attempt to resolve a dispute amicably – for instance, by
engaging in friendly discussions, submitting to mediation or
undertaking good faith negotiations – before the commencement
of arbitration proceedings. There has been much ado about the
enforceability of such clauses and whether they should be
considered void due to vagueness: how does one engage in
"friendly discussions", and what exactly are "good
faith negotiations", when a presumably acrimonious dispute has
already arisen between parties?
Despite this ambiguity, courts have increasingly found tiered
dispute-resolution clauses to be enforceable. In fact, with a view
to combat rising pendency in courts, these principles have been
extended to the initiation of litigation as well. The Commercial
Courts Act, 2015 (CCA) was amended