Summary
Trustees often seek to limit their liability in the form of
exoneration clauses in trust deeds. As such, it is generally
difficult for a beneficiary to challenge a trustee’s decision
that falls within the scope of the exoneration clause.
In Sofer v SwissIndependent Trustees SA
[2019] EWHC 2071 (Ch), the England and Wales High Court
confirmed just how high the bar can be for beneficiaries to
overcome the limitation on liability provided by exoneration
clauses and also set out a test for doing so. Here the defendant
(the trustee) applied for striking out or summary judgment of a
claim pursued by a beneficiary for breach of trust, on the basis
that the trustee’s relevant action was covered by an
exoneration clause. The strike out was granted.