Why Finality Demands Attention
There are few principles in dispute resolution that carry the
weight of res judicata. The idea that a matter, once
finally decided, should not be relitigated is foundational to every
legal system on earth. It shields parties from the burden and
expense of perpetual litigation, conserves the resources of
adjudicators, and underpins the basic social compact that disputes
must, at some point, come to rest. In international commercial
arbitration, where parties from different legal traditions and
different jurisdictions submit their disputes to private tribunals
under different substantive laws, the principle takes on even
greater significance. And yet, in my experience, it is one of those
areas where the practice has long lagged behind the aspiration.