On June 23, 2020, the Federal Court of Justice ("FCJ")
overturned the Düsseldorf Court of Appeals'
("DCA") interim decision and rejected Facebook Inc.'s
("Facebook") request to suspend the enforceability of the
Federal Cartel Office's ("FCO") prohibition
decision.1
The FCJ disagreed with the FCO's determination of an abuse
based on a violation of data protection law, but instead examined
Facebook's data usage exclusively under competition law.
Although the FCJ implicitly rejected the FCO's reasoning,
the decision amounts to a major victory for the German authority
whose order was reviewed quite critically by the DCA in the first
instance. As a direct consequence, Facebook must end its
practice of combining user data from different sources without the
users' explicit consent. It must also change its terms
and conditions in Germany within 12 months. The
FCJ's ruling was rendered in summary proceedings and the court
has yet to publish the full judgment.