The recent judgment of the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal
193/2016 is an important reminder that, in the sensitive field of
compulsory Expropriations, the judicial power to
determine "fair and reasonable compensation" is not
unlimited. The Court does indeed have the discretion to accept or
reject elements from the experts' reports, but it is obliged to
exercise that discretion with clear, reasoned and
well-substantiated findings.
The case concerned a 987 sq.m. property in Limassol, which was
expropriated for the construction of school facilities. The
Limassol District Court had determined its value at €328.68
per sq.m., awarding an additional amount of €127,007 to the
owner. The Republic challenged the decision, focusing its appeal on
the allegedly erroneous use of the comparable sale S3.