Introduction – The Amalgamation and the Alleged Tax
Avoidance Transaction
The Tax Court of Canada recently decided a case regarding the
Section 245 General Anti-Avoidance Rule ("GAAR") of the
Income Tax Act. In Birchcliff Energy Ltd. v. The Queen,
the Court used the GAAR to deny the use of non-capital losses in an
amalgamation.
The facts are as follows. Birchcliff was interested in acquiring
Veracel, partly to take advantage of Veracel's previous tax
losses. Initially, Birchcliff's value outweighed Veracel's.
Unfortunately for Birchcliff, clause 256(7)(b)(iii)(B) of the
Income Tax Act, on amalgamation, deems control of the
smaller of two unrelated amalgamating predecessor corporations to
be acquired. Under the loss streaming restrictions in subsection
111(5) of the Income Tax Act, this meant that the losses
of the smaller predecessor corporation (Veracel) would only be
deductible against income of the amalgamated corporation from
income generated by business