On November 7, 2016, the Court of Appeal delivered a judgment
that establishes the limits of jurisdiction of cities in the
creation of conservation areas (2646-8926 Québec
inc. v. Lorraine (Ville de), 2016 QCCA 1803). The
facts in this case are as follows.
In 1989, 2646-8926 Québec inc. (hereinafter 2646-8926)
purchased land in the city of Lorraine to build a real estate
project. At the time it was acquired, the property was located in a
residential area. In 1991, the city rezoned the land. With the
change, approximately 60% of the plot owned by 2646-8926 became a
conservation area, which blocked the residential project on a
portion of land.
It was only in 2001 that the landowner (2646-8926) noticed that
the city had built walking and skiing trails, benches and stairs on
the property. Shortly after, the landowner became aware of urban
regulation U-91 that rezoned most of the land. In 2007, he
initiated legal proceedings in Superior Court to revoke the bylaw,
which