On October 10, 2012, the Québec Court of Appeal rendered
a most interesting judgment for owners and managers of commercial
real estate.1
In May 1976, Samen Investments Inc. acquires the Gordon Brown
Building on De Maisonneuve Boulevard West, near Bleury Street.
Samen immediately entrusts its management to Monit Management
Limited pursuant to a contract that will remain in force for some
28 years. In September 2003, Samen advises Monit that the
management contract will end on December 31 of that same year.
An inspection of the Gordon Brown Building by Gestion Sidev
Inc., the property management firm hired by Samen to replace Monit,
reveals that parts of the structure of the underground parking
garage are deteriorated to the point of having to be demolished and
rebuilt. In a letter sent to Monit by Samen's lawyers, the
owner claims that Monit is responsible for the poor state of repair
of the concrete slab, having neglected to perform appropriate
maintenance and