On May 18, 2017, the Ontario Court of Appeal ("the
Court") released its decision in Black v. Owen. The
appeal concerned the enforceability of the appellants' legal
obligation to pay an annual levy as their contribution toward
maintenance costs for private roads and other common areas in
Wychwood Park, a residential area within the City of Toronto. The
payment obligation arose under an 1891 Trust Deed (the "Trust
Deed") registered on title to the lands within Wychwood
Park.
In its unanimous decision, the three-judge panel of the Court
held that "the obligation under the Trust Deed to pay the
annual levy is unenforceable as against the
appellants".
By way of background, Wychwood Park is a small community of 60
residential properties situated within a central area of the City
of Toronto. In 1874, Marmaduke Matthews built the first house in
the neighbourhood, and in 1888, residents registered a plan of
subdivision. The objective at the time was to create an
artists'