A January 2023 court decision from Ontario, XPL Construction
Solutions Inc. v. North Bay Capital Investments Ltd.,
dealt with a motion by the Defendant, North Bay Capital Investments
Ltd. ("North Bay"), seeking an order to,
among other things, discharge a construction lien pursuant to s. 47
of the Construction Act SO 1990, c C.30 (the
"Act").
Specifically, North Bay argued that the subject construction
lien should be discharged pursuant to s. 47(1)(a) of the
Act on the basis that the plaintiff, XPL Construction
Solutions Inc. ("XPL"), had engaged in
an abuse of process.
The central issue on the motion was what constitutes an
"abuse of process" in the context of s.47 of the
Act, and whether the amount of XPL's claim for lien,
or its conduct, could be fairly described as frivolous, vexatious
or an abuse of process. As Justice Spencer Nicholson noted in his
reasons, this is an issue which has received little judicial
discussion to date.