Edwards v McCarthy, 2019 ONSC 3925
Key Takeaway: Service of an expert report by a defendant does
not automatically mean the expert will be called to testify at
trial. While it is necessary to serve a Rule 53.03 compliant expert
report in order to later call that expert at trial, it does not
automatically follow that service of the report will result in the
expert being called. As a result, service of an expert report at
the discovery stage does not automatically trigger disclosure
obligations.
Mr. Edwards was in a car accident and brought a claim for
statutory accident benefits. His former lawyer, Mr. McCarthy,
recommended a settlement. Mr. Edwards alleged the settlement
recommendation was improvident and, as a result, he brought a
lawyer's negligence claim.