Last month
we wrote about the ongoing debate
in British Columbia over sequencing of certification and other
applications in class actions. Now, the B.C. Court of Appeal has
weighed in. Its decision in British Columbia v. The Jean Coutu
Group (PJC) Inc., 2021 BCCA 219 will shake up law
in British Columbia on sequencing in four significant ways.
First, the court rejected outright the notion
that there is a presumption that certification should be the first
procedural application heard in a proposed class action. Instead,
each sequencing application must be decided on its own facts in the
context of the particular case. The court was clear that
"[t]he cases that have [held there was a presumption
certification goes first] were, in my opinion, wrongly decided and
should not be followed" (para. 37).