In Resler v. Anglin, 2026 SCC 23, the Supreme Court of Canada held that an unsuccessful provincial election candidate may continue his civil action in misfeasance in public office against Alberta’s Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) for alleged bad faith conduct during an election campaign. The Court confirmed that such claims were not barred by the doctrine of collateral attack, abuse of process, parliamentary privilege, or a statutory immunity clause, given that he did not seek to invalidate the election result itself and was alleging bad faith misconduct on the CEO’s part.
The decision highlights the boundary between public law and private law remedies, which generally permits torts claims against public officials where they are alleged to have acted in bad faith. While these claims will be permitted to proceed to the merits where they are properly pleaded, establishing misfeasance in public office is a high bar, not a “free-for-all”, and successful claims on the merits are rare.