Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 18 AUGUST 2016

Ross-Clair v. Canada (Attorney General): Judge's Failure To Consider Contract As A Whole Leads To Correctness Review

The Ontario Court of Appeal's decision in Ross-Clair v. Canada (Attorney General)is another post-Sattva instance of a dispute over the standard of review of contract interpretation. For a unanimous Court of Appeal, Justice Epstein reviewed the application judge's interpretation of a contract on the correctness standard.

CanadaLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration

The Ontario Court of Appeal's decision in Ross-Clair v. Canada (Attorney General)is another post-Sattva instance of a dispute over the standard of review of contract interpretation. For a unanimous Court of Appeal, Justice Epstein reviewed the application judge's interpretation of a contract on the correctness standard. She did so not because the contract was standard form (as was the appellant's primary argument) but because the trial judge committed an extricable error of law by reading a particular provision in the contract in isolation and thus failing to consider the contract as a whole. She held:

[45] In my view, the decision is reviewable on a standard of correctness.

[46]  I do not come to this conclusion based on a finding as to the nature of the Contract. Although it may be appropriate to regard the Contract as a standard form agreement, the interpretation of which is subject to review on a correctness standard, it is difficult to arrive at a

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from