Every day in Canada, police forces, the CRA, and other
investigative agencies seize huge amounts of data in the course of
their investigations. Rather than narrowly focusing on gathering
documents relevant to their investigation, they routinely seize
entire computer hard drives or entire servers. This systemic
approach has a number of troubling aspects to it. The focus of this
article, however, is on the ability of our judicial system to
uphold the protections guaranteed by legal privilege that are in
jeopardy due to systemic over-seizure.
Released in 2019, the British Columbia Supreme Court (the
"BCSC") decision Solicitor-Client
Privilege of Things Seized (Re), 2019 BCSC 91,1 considered
appropriate measures for handling seized electronic files that
included privileged communications. The decision provides a
practical review of solicitor-client privilege and the safe
handling of potentially privileged materials seized by the
state. At a high level, the decision