In DALI 675 Pension Fund v SNC Lavalin, 2019 ONSC 6512,
the Ontario Superior Court provided guidance about the court's
ability to stay a class action at the pre-certification stage.
Belobaba J. addressed whether a proposed class action, that arises
from the same set of facts as another action commenced in another
province, could be stayed on the ground of abuse of process. The
court confirmed that parallel proceedings per se are not
an abuse of process. Parallel proceedings may be an abuse of
process where there is compelling evidence that one of the
proceedings was duplicative when filed, and was filed for no
legitimate purpose.
Background
In the case, two proposed national class actions with different
representative plaintiffs were launched in Ontario and Quebec
against the same defendant. The pleadings in both actions allege
securities misrepresentations and are substantially similar in
scope and content. The damages claim is over a billion dollars. At
the time