In Hacopian-Armen Estate v. Mahmoud, 2021
ONCA 545, the Court of Appeal for Ontario considered issues of
factual and legal causation in the context of medical negligence
cases involving competing expert evidence.
Overview
The plaintiff, Armineh Hacopian-Armen, died on August 24, 2011,
as a result of Stage IV uterine leiomyosarcoma ("uLMS").
The respondents, members of her family, brought this action against
the appellant, her gynecologist. They alleged that the appellant
was negligent when he examined Ms. Hacopian-Armen on May 25, 2009,
in failing to conduct an endometrial biopsy, a simple in-office
procedure for the detection of uterine pathologies and
abnormalities. The respondents claimed that this would probably
have detected her cancer at an early stage, when treatment would
likely have been effective.