In a recent decision, the Ontario Court of Appeal confirmed that
when guarantors are contractually on the hook for a guarantee,
their liability will not be affected by a separate postponement
agreement, unless that was clearly the intentions of the parties.
To find otherwise, the Court stated, would lead to a result that is
not only unfair, but also "absurd".
In, Sicotte v 239153 Ontario Ltd., Joanne Sicotte
loaned $800,000 to 2399153 Ontario Ltd. (the
"Company") in 2014 in exchange for a
mortgage over a commercial property held by the Company. Pursuant
to a separate guarantee agreement, three officers, directors, and
shareholders of the Company (the
"Guarantors") agreed to guarantee the
debts and liabilities of the Company "at any time owing"
to Ms. Sicotte.